PDA

View Full Version : USB 2.0 not utilizing high speed in Linux



Bothersome
06-01-2004, 08:45 PM
Anyone have any luck at all getting any version of Linux to utilize the high speed mode of their USB 2.0 card?

I have no problems with getting any of my USB stuff to work in Knoppix 3.4 or Debian or Mandrake 10.0. But all version are only using the USB in the slow mode (v1.1). It would be nice to get it to high speed. In Win2000 I get a huge speed increase. I can copy a 4 meg file in less than 2 seconds in Win2000. On Linux it takes about 7 seconds or about 600KB/s.

Is there some driver that must be loaded to get the speed up?

Using an 80Gig external USB drive in slow mode can be painfull.

Card in question is a Belkin USB 2.0 PCI card.

Kenneth

kelmo
06-02-2004, 09:44 AM
su-to-root and:
'modprobe ehci-hcd'

Maybe then have a look:
'dmesg |grep ehci'

Then to have it start (as it should) every time you boot into knoppix, add ehci-hcd to /etc/modules-2.x.xx

cintra
06-02-2004, 09:57 AM
Anyone have any luck at all getting any version of Linux to utilize the high speed mode of their USB 2.0 card?

I have no problems with getting any of my USB stuff to work in Knoppix 3.4 or Debian or Mandrake 10.0. But all version are only using the USB in the slow mode (v1.1). It would be nice to get it to high speed. In Win2000 I get a huge speed increase. I can copy a 4 meg file in less than 2 seconds in Win2000. On Linux it takes about 7 seconds or about 600KB/s.

Is there some driver that must be loaded to get the speed up?

Using an 80Gig external USB drive in slow mode can be painfull.

Card in question is a Belkin USB 2.0 PCI card.

Kenneth

Hei

Until yesterday I was sure my Asus p4pe motherboard's usb hubs were 1.1 &/or 2.0. I found however that the 3 hubs available on the back of my machine are actually 1.1 only, while the single 2.0 hub requires installation of game port i/o hardware!

Are you sure yours are 2.0 hubs? Info Center USB devices shows the right info in my case..

regards

Bothersome
06-03-2004, 10:48 PM
I'm sure. The exact same hardware/cabling/ports/drives show a large difference in speed with reguard to Win2000 vs Knoppix/Debian/Mandrake 10.

I'll give kelmo's suggestions a try when I get home.

ktheking
06-08-2004, 09:25 PM
Try booting with the linux26 cheatcode .

el_supremo
06-21-2004, 05:33 AM
su-to-root and:
'modprobe ehci-hcd'

Maybe then have a look:
'dmesg |grep ehci'

Then to have it start (as it should) every time you boot into knoppix, add ehci-hcd to /etc/modules-2.x.xx

Hi Kelmo:
Your suggested fix worked for my problem with USB2 throughput but can you please explain in more detail what you mean about changing /etc/modules-2.x.xx? I can only find a /etc/modules and it doesn't contain anything.
Also, would I have to burn a new CD to make this change permanent or is there some way to change files in /etc without a burn?
I've come up with a way to modify knoppix.sh in such a way that it is not overridden by doing a save Knoppix configuration so I have put the modprobe command in there for now.

Thanks
Pete

kelmo
06-21-2004, 11:40 PM
el_supremo, I was commenting on a hdd install of knoppix where each modules list 'wears' the suffix of the kernel it corresponds to. (/etc/modules-2.65 & /etc/modules-2.4.26) There also exists /etc/modules, which transiently represents the contents of the module lists for each specific kernel as they are active.

In knoppix cd mode there is some 'magic' that handles kernel modules automatically, hence the success of the distro. So it would be very difficult to 'properly' modify a remaster with such changes without intimate knowledge of how the hardware autoconfig works. There may exist a way to make the changes to a remastered cd which would work for only your system?!

el_supremo
06-22-2004, 12:13 AM
Thanks Kelmo.

Pete

ewangr
12-10-2004, 07:06 PM
su-to-root and:
'modprobe ehci-hcd'

Maybe then have a look:
'dmesg |grep ehci'

Then to have it start (as it should) every time you boot into knoppix, add ehci-hcd to /etc/modules-2.x.xx

FWIW, this doesn't seem to work with the 2.6 kernel of Knoppix 3.6 after an HD Install. Though it works just fine for 2.4.27. Does it work for you if you run off the CD using Knoppix26?

Thanks,
Ewan