-
Senior Member
registered user
@klaus2008
If I understand correctly, the /etc/init.d/knoppix-startx file
has a single long line to which you merely add material via a tee command.
I dont look for every instance of 'startx', do I?
And that I should save a copy of the init.d file before so editing.
Have I got that right?
Last edited by utu; 07-31-2010 at 12:13 AM.
-
Senior Member
registered user
@utu:
The file /etc/init.d/knoppix-startx is a file with many lines of code. But there is only one long line with startx being issued.
Code:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1 ; RC="$?"
I changed this line so that the output goes into a log file and to virtual terminal #6 instead of vt #5 since vt #5 is invisible while the Xserver is running.
Code:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 2>&1 | /usr/bin/tee -a /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log >/dev/tty6 ; RC="$?"
I think it is always a good idea to make a backup copy of the file before altering it.
-
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
klaus2008
@utu:
The file /etc/init.d/knoppix-startx is a file with many lines of code. But there is only one long line with startx being issued.
Code:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1 ; RC="$?"
I changed this line so that the output goes into a log file and to virtual terminal #6 instead of vt #5 since vt #5 is invisible while the Xserver is running.
Code:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 2>&1 | /usr/bin/tee -a /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log >/dev/tty6 ; RC="$?"
I think it is always a good idea to make a backup copy of the file before altering it.
One can also make a backup of knoppix-data.XXX to be certain that whatever changes are made can be entirely overridden in case a problem develops unexpectedly. Sometimes things just start acting goofy without much in the way of clues about what is needed to fix it.
Cheers!
Krishna
-
Senior Member
registered user
@klauss2008:
Houston, we have a problem.
This line has a syntax error, according to Knoppix, cut-and-pasted from my new /etc/init.d/knoppix-startx:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 2>&1 | /usr/bin/tee -a /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log >/dev/tty6 ; RC="$?"
This is the line you suggested, cut-and-pasted from Knoppix forum:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 2>&1 | /usr/bin/tee -a /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log >/dev/tty6 ; RC="$?"
-
Senior Member
registered user
@Klauss2008:
The original Knoppix line ends with:
"$USER" </dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1 ; RC="$?"
Should we now have at this point:
"$USER" </dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1; | /usr/bin/tee...
-
Senior Member
registered user
I/O Redirection
@utu:
Code:
exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp </dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1
The intention is to direct input from /dev/tty5 to the program /usr/bin/startx and redirect the output from stdout and stderr to /dev/tty5. But the output is invisible while the Xserver is running.
Code:
exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp </dev/tty5 2>&1 | /usr/bin/tee -a /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log >/dev/tty6 ; RC="$?"
The aim is to redirect /usr/bin/startx's output (stdout plus stderr) to /usr/bin/tee via a pipe. The program /usr/bin/tee appends its input to the file /var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log or creates that file if it does not exist. In addition the tee program's output is redirected to /dev/tty6.
If you do not need the output on a terminal then you could try
Code:
su -l -c "export STARTUP=$STARTUP ; exec /usr/bin/startx -- vt5 -dpi "$DPI" -br -noreset -nolisten tcp" "$USER" </dev/tty5 >>/var/log/knoppix-startx-dev-tty5.log 2>&1 ; RC="$?"
Maybe you are interested in reading more about I/O Redirection in the Advanced Bash-Scripting Guide: http://tldp.org/LDP/abs/html/io-redirection.html
There is also a simple example of using a pipe in the BASH Programming - Introduction HOW-TO http://tldp.org/HOWTO/Bash-Prog-Intro-HOWTO-4.html
If you write a semicolon ; then the Bash thinks that you want to mark the end of a command. In the example
Code:
</dev/tty5 >/dev/tty5 2>&1; | /usr/bin/tee
is no program that delivers input to the pipe. Thus you should get an error message.
-
Senior Member
registered user
@klauss2008
I appreciate your tutelage, but I'd like to stick with your first suggestion.
As near as I can tell, I have exactly input your first proposed command.
If I have, there is a syntax error in it.
If I haven't then I can't see the difference.
Perhaps you can look more closely at my post #24, forget my post #25, and
see what needs to be done.
I think this might be the simplest way to proceed at this point.
I grasp your idea, but I'd like to defer 'understanding' the syntax to later.
So, is there a difference in the two lines I posted in #24?
Thanks for your patience.
-
Senior Member
registered user
@utu:
I do not see the difference between the two lines in your post #24. I put the old and the new knoppix-startx in a zip file so that you can compare them yourself. I do not get any syntax error messages and the log file is created as expected.
knoppix-startx.zip
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
As near as I can tell, I have exactly input your first proposed command.
If I have, there is a syntax error in it.
If I haven't then I can't see the difference.
How do you know that there is a syntax error ? Did you arrive at the conclusion based on the log file produced ? But 'tee' command appends to the log, so it could be the previous 'startx' which produced the syntax error. I suggest you remove the '-a' in the 'tee' command and test it again. This will make sure you are not seeing the history.
-
Senior Member
registered user
@kl522 & klauss2008
Doing as root...
Having revised /knoppix-startx, either with or without -a in the tee command,
when I ctl-alt-backspace, I get the syntax error, and am locked out of X for 5 min.
Reboot gives the same syntax & lock-out situation
I get back here by re-writing knoppix-startx from knoppix-startx.orig
which I saved before we began tinkering with X itself.
I get the idea, however, this is not actually the file I want per se.
This file probably duplicates only a segment of the whole on-screen experience
that originally got my curiosity.
I can probably figure out the syntax problem on my own, eventually, I just thought
it might be obvious to some of the old hands at this.
If I can't figure this problem out in a short while, I think I need to research the init process
and get to understand it better. I've always felt like a daredevil when tinkering with
the guts of the X machinery up close.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
![NEW SonicWALL TZ350 02-SSC-0942 1.0 Gbps 5x 1GB RJ-45 Firewall picture](/store/img/g/KuQAAOSwkSNmYMwN/s-l225/NEW-SonicWALL-TZ350-02-SSC-0942-1-0-Gbps-5x-1GB-RJ.jpg)
NEW SonicWALL TZ350 02-SSC-0942 1.0 Gbps 5x 1GB RJ-45 Firewall
$199.99
![SonicWall TZ400 Security Appliance - 01-SSC-0213 Firewall picture](/store/img/g/9W0AAOSwcFtlyRo9/s-l225/SonicWall-TZ400-Security-Appliance-01-SSC-0213-Fir.jpg)
SonicWall TZ400 Security Appliance - 01-SSC-0213 Firewall
$350.00
![Palo Alto PA-3050 Enterprise Firewall Security picture](/store/img/g/ok0AAOSwvRdmj~5z/s-l225/Palo-Alto-PA-3050-Enterprise-Firewall-Security.jpg)
Palo Alto PA-3050 Enterprise Firewall Security
$70.00
![Netgate SG-1100 Pfsense+ Firewall Appliance picture](/store/img/g/L10AAOSwJelmkUQt/s-l225/Netgate-SG-1100-Pfsense-Firewall-Appliance.jpg)
Netgate SG-1100 Pfsense+ Firewall Appliance
$100.00
![Fortinet Fortigate 80E FG-80E Next Generation VPN Firewall picture](/store/img/g/POoAAOSwQ6NmjFQo/s-l225/Fortinet-Fortigate-80E-FG-80E-Next-Generation-VPN-.jpg)
Fortinet Fortigate 80E FG-80E Next Generation VPN Firewall
$49.99
![Cisco Meraki Z3-HW Firewall Cloud Managed Security Appliance picture](/store/img/g/izwAAOSwSBVle4ch/s-l225/Cisco-Meraki-Z3-HW-Firewall-Cloud-Managed-Security.jpg)
Cisco Meraki Z3-HW Firewall Cloud Managed Security Appliance
$39.00
![SOPHOS XG 135 Rev.3 Next Generation Firewall Sophos Ltd. XG135 Rev 3 picture](/store/img/g/Nq4AAOSwHzplOcFW/s-l225/SOPHOS-XG-135-Rev-3-Next-Generation-Firewall-Sopho.jpg)
SOPHOS XG 135 Rev.3 Next Generation Firewall Sophos Ltd. XG135 Rev 3
$108.00
![pfSense Firewall VPN AES-NI Celeron N3350 1.10GHz 10GB RAM 80GB SSD 5x Intel NIC picture](/store/img/g/ObkAAOSwQuhi9bAX/s-l225/pfSense-Firewall-VPN-AES-NI-Celeron-N3350-1-10GHz-.jpg)
pfSense Firewall VPN AES-NI Celeron N3350 1.10GHz 10GB RAM 80GB SSD 5x Intel NIC
$91.00
![Sophos SG 230 Firewall Security Appliance Ubuntu Server 22.04 LTS 🧡 picture](/store/img/g/IpEAAOSw83FmkHht/s-l225/Sophos-SG-230-Firewall-Security-Appliance-Ubuntu-S.jpg)
Sophos SG 230 Firewall Security Appliance Ubuntu Server 22.04 LTS 🧡
$175.00
![Cisco ASA 5506-X Adaptive 8-Port Security Firewall Appliance picture](/store/img/g/6csAAOSwxuhmhUw-/s-l225/Cisco-ASA-5506-X-Adaptive-8-Port-Security-Firewall.jpg)
Cisco ASA 5506-X Adaptive 8-Port Security Firewall Appliance
$49.99