-
Senior Member
registered user
I have started researching 'ntfs-3g' on this forum and find that
using ntfs for remastering was a hot topic in early May of this
year. Use the forum search function to see where Forester
suggested it in so many words.
Some of the current cast of characters on this topic were then
just as uncertain about its advisability as I have expressed.
What was the Defining Experience that made you (anyone) become
less concerned with whether this was a risky business or not?
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
I have started researching 'ntfs-3g' on this forum and find that
using ntfs for remastering was a hot topic in early May of this
year. Use the forum search function to see where Forester
suggested it in so many words.
Some of the current cast of characters on this topic were then
just as uncertain about its advisability as I have expressed.
What was the Defining Experience that made you (anyone) become
less concerned with whether this was a risky business or not?
First, you have to distingush between full use of NTFS, e.g. for file system administration, and the very restricted use with this method, For instance, I would not recommend expanding the store files, rather create them anew, as I did with store.img yesterday.
Second, there is an issue of relative risk. And the relative risk using ntfs-3g relative to using NTFS natively, is way lower than I had realized.
Third, the use of NTFS for such purposes is exploding. Are the error reports also exploding, from competent users? Go figure.
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
What was the Defining Experience that made you (anyone) become
less concerned with whether this was a risky business or not?
I wouldn't say poor-man install on NTFS and running knoppix fuse/ntfs-3g is totally safe, considering that in my opinion, the original Knoppix does not shutdown properly, especially on fuse/NTFS. However, it is definitely safer than trying to use Win7 VHD on Linux.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Yes, but should that be a threat for Windows?
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
kl522
I wouldn't say poor-man install on NTFS and running knoppix fuse/ntfs-3g is totally safe, considering that in my opinion, the original Knoppix does not shutdown properly, especially on fuse/NTFS. However, it is definitely safer than trying to use Win7 VHD on Linux.
Sure, but I perceive this mostly to be a problem for Knoppix. Persistent image is inherently unsafe storage because of non-proper shutdown. If lack of proper file closure causes a file system corruption problem after random access to an established, allocation-wise unchanged file, then NTFS is worse than I am able to believe it is. Any program, at any time, might get stuck and die, leaving open files behind, and Windows can't rely on any special OS monitor being alive and kicking at the time to fix it.
Do you think this bug may corrupt NTFS?
In any case, please register this as a bug, as you know so much about it, and have a fix: http://www.knoppix.net/wiki/Bugs/6.4.4DVD. Very nice if you could include your patch(es) too. Of course, Klaus K is completely free to ignore all bug reports/suggestions, but the bug pages on the wiki here have been actively used by Klaus&co in earlier releases.
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
Capricorny
Of course, Klaus K is completely free to ignore all bug reports/suggestions, but the bug pages on the wiki here have been actively used by Klaus&co in earlier releases.
I think the first bug which needs to be logged is the extra /dev/loop/0 thingie. For decades, this unwanted "feature" has been around to bother all knoppix users, and Klaus&co are still totally unaware of it.
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
kl522
I think the first bug which needs to be logged is the extra /dev/loop/0 thingie. For decades, this unwanted "feature" has been around to bother all knoppix users, and Klaus&co are still totally unaware of it.
Then go ahead and log it! I don't want to "spam" the knoppix-devel list with lots of detailed bug reports, but presenting a list of bugs/misfeatures, we may expect them to be corrected.
And that shutdown thing is important, I think, so please file it.
BTW, I think Knoppix just turned 10
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
![ORICO 5 Bay Raid Enclosure USB3.0 SATA External Hard Drive Enclosure Up to 80TB picture](/store/img/g/m2IAAOSwmz5kyNFT/s-l225/ORICO-5-Bay-Raid-Enclosure-USB3-0-SATA-External-Ha.jpg)
ORICO 5 Bay Raid Enclosure USB3.0 SATA External Hard Drive Enclosure Up to 80TB
$115.59
![Dell EMC 092GD6 Broadcom 9305-16i LSI Quad Port 4 Port SAS RAID Controller picture](/store/img/g/ph8AAOSwnHxmXzcB/s-l225/Dell-EMC-092GD6-Broadcom-9305-16i-LSI-Quad-Port-4-.jpg)
Dell EMC 092GD6 Broadcom 9305-16i LSI Quad Port 4 Port SAS RAID Controller
$84.99
![8 Bay Tool Less Tray Hot Swap 2.5](/store/img/g/3qgAAOSwoa9mfrgW/s-l225/8-Bay-Tool-Less-Tray-Hot-Swap-2-5-3-5-SATA-Non-RAI.jpg)
8 Bay Tool Less Tray Hot Swap 2.5" 3.5" SATA Non RAID Ext USB 3.0 Enclosure USED
$145.00
![ORICO 5 Bay Raid USB3.0 to SATA External Hard Drive Enclosure for 3.5'' HDD LOT picture](/store/img/g/m2IAAOSwmz5kyNFT/s-l225/ORICO-5-Bay-Raid-USB3-0-to-SATA-External-Hard-Driv.jpg)
ORICO 5 Bay Raid USB3.0 to SATA External Hard Drive Enclosure for 3.5'' HDD LOT
$134.39
![ASUS Hyper M.2 x16 Gen 4 RAID Card- Used Working picture](/store/img/g/fGwAAOSwAStmfi9c/s-l225/ASUS-Hyper-M-2-x16-Gen-4-RAID-Card-Used-Working.jpg)
ASUS Hyper M.2 x16 Gen 4 RAID Card- Used Working
$32.95
![Dell PERC H330 PCIe 3.0 x8 RAID Storage Controller 4Y5H1 High Profile picture](/store/img/g/C7YAAOSwLYJl3nQQ/s-l225/Dell-PERC-H330-PCIe-3-0-x8-RAID-Storage-Controller.jpg)
Dell PERC H330 PCIe 3.0 x8 RAID Storage Controller 4Y5H1 High Profile
$17.99
![Broadcom LSI 9400-16i Raid card SAS/SATA/NVME SFF-8643 SAS3416 PCIe 3.1 x8 HBA picture](/store/img/g/SM4AAOSwsEVmhD1K/s-l225/Broadcom-LSI-9400-16i-Raid-card-SAS-SATA-NVME-SFF-.jpg)
Broadcom LSI 9400-16i Raid card SAS/SATA/NVME SFF-8643 SAS3416 PCIe 3.1 x8 HBA
$95.00
![WD TB My Book Duo Desktop RAID External Hard Drive 0TB NO DRIVES picture](/store/img/g/Zm8AAOSwM0VmO6v~/s-l225/WD-TB-My-Book-Duo-Desktop-RAID-External-Hard-Drive.jpg)
WD TB My Book Duo Desktop RAID External Hard Drive 0TB NO DRIVES
$42.00
![OWC Guardian Maximus Raid Enclosure SATA Hard Drive FireWire picture](/store/img/g/-FoAAOSwtEBmQ5qa/s-l225/OWC-Guardian-Maximus-Raid-Enclosure-SATA-Hard-Driv.jpg)
OWC Guardian Maximus Raid Enclosure SATA Hard Drive FireWire
$36.99
![Yottamaster 5 Bay RAID Hard Drive Enclosure Type-C B For 2.5](/store/img/g/izoAAOSwfCZlZs9y/s-l225/Yottamaster-5-Bay-RAID-Hard-Drive-Enclosure-Type-C.jpg)
Yottamaster 5 Bay RAID Hard Drive Enclosure Type-C B For 2.5" 3.5" SATA HDD SSDs
$139.99