-
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
Greetings again, Forester
Hi utu,
I quite liked your description (post #7, this thread) of what you want the first time I read it. It is a fair reflection of what I think we discussed way back when.
I don't know that others will understand it quite the same way. Some might not recognise it as 'remastering', some might wonder what is so special about this set of requirements. I seem to remember KK himself wondering why bother.
I still think you have a valid point to make but it needs to be able to made convincingly.
When I think of what is involved in remastering I see a 'selection' of what to include, 'assembling' what is selected, 'generating' a new image from the assembly and, of course, 'testing, testing, testing'. Others might see it differently - they might include publishing the new image, for example. I think the process is iterative and I'd see testing as continual, rather than something that is done at the end.
In the middle of all this, the 'generation' bit may not seem all that important but that was all we were really talking about. Perhaps our approach is a bit to simplistic. I don't think so but you would need to convince the skeptics.
You start with a working LiveUSB installation. You use synaptic to add a few packages and may be remove a few others. That covers 'selection'. You've also covered 'assembly': everything is in your persistent store. You've been playing with the new packages as you've installed them. That covers 'testing' too (for all practical purposes). So all you need is the 'generation' bit and that isn't something you can do with a click or two of the mouse.
This may not be 'remastering' as KK knows it but it seems to be a reasonable scenario (at least) for the 'ordinary' user's first attempts at remastering. I think there is a case of providing a simple (to use) tool for this.
Do this make sense ? Is there any point in my continuing ? It only gets harder from here on.
The next questions you might be asked as about the scope the method covers (like is this LiveUSB only ?). There is no problem with there being limitations but it helps if you know what they are. Open discussion may help widen the scope at little cost and bring others on board.
P.S. Still interested in the special properties of ntfs for remastering.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
![IBM System X3250 M3 Server 8GB RAM Intel Xeon x3440 2.53ghz (NO HDD) picture](/store/img/M~sAAOSwFVlkVr-r/s-l225//IBM-System-X3250-M3-Server-8GB-RAM-Intel-Xeon-x344.jpg)
IBM System X3250 M3 Server 8GB RAM Intel Xeon x3440 2.53ghz (NO HDD)
$41.99
![IBM System x3250 M4 Server Intel Xeon E31220/3.10Ghz RAM 16GB HDD 2TB picture](/store/img/faAAAOSwNpBmmurh/s-l225//IBM-System-x3250-M4-Server-Intel-Xeon-E31220-3-10G.jpg)
IBM System x3250 M4 Server Intel Xeon E31220/3.10Ghz RAM 16GB HDD 2TB
$79.00
![IBM Power S822 8284-22A 12SFF Power8 3.89GHz 6Core 64GB RAM No HDD Server System picture](/store/img/xiEAAOSwwGtmRmN6/s-l225//IBM-Power-S822-8284-22A-12SFF-Power8-3-89GHz-6Core.jpg)
IBM Power S822 8284-22A 12SFF Power8 3.89GHz 6Core 64GB RAM No HDD Server System
$314.99
![IBM EServer Xseries 220 Desktop Computer Intel Pentium 3 1GHz 512MB Ram No HDD picture](/store/img/u88AAOSw9sxmltD4/s-l225//IBM-EServer-Xseries-220-Desktop-Computer-Intel-Pen.jpg)
IBM EServer Xseries 220 Desktop Computer Intel Pentium 3 1GHz 512MB Ram No HDD
$224.99
![IBM Server Rack Cabinet Machine Type 9308 Model 42P w/ Mounting Accessories picture](/store/img/9r4AAOSw0lNmkTwe/s-l225//IBM-Server-Rack-Cabinet-Machine-Type-9308-Model-42.jpg)
IBM Server Rack Cabinet Machine Type 9308 Model 42P w/ Mounting Accessories
$379.99
![IBM System X3650 M4 7915AC1 Server 2*Intel Xeon E5-2640 2.5GHz 32GB SEE NOTES picture](/store/img/GXwAAOSwPUBmlreB/s-l225//IBM-System-X3650-M4-7915AC1-Server-2-Intel-Xeon-E5.jpg)
IBM System X3650 M4 7915AC1 Server 2*Intel Xeon E5-2640 2.5GHz 32GB SEE NOTES
$59.00
![IBM System x3550 M3 Dual Intel Xeon X5650 @2.67GHz 32GB RAM No HDD picture](/store/img/oRsAAOSw~pRmQitC/s-l225//IBM-System-x3550-M3-Dual-Intel-Xeon-X5650-2-67GHz-.jpg)
IBM System x3550 M3 Dual Intel Xeon X5650 @2.67GHz 32GB RAM No HDD
$68.50
![IBM Power S822 8284-22A 12SFF Power8 3.89GHz 6Core 512GB RAM No HDD Server picture](/store/img/gB8AAOSwbdlmoAB0/s-l225//IBM-Power-S822-8284-22A-12SFF-Power8-3-89GHz-6Core.jpg)
IBM Power S822 8284-22A 12SFF Power8 3.89GHz 6Core 512GB RAM No HDD Server
$999.00
![IBM System x3250 M4 Server Intel Xeon E31220/3.10Ghz RAM 16GB HDD 1TB picture](/store/img/faAAAOSwNpBmmurh/s-l225//IBM-System-x3250-M4-Server-Intel-Xeon-E31220-3-10G.jpg)
IBM System x3250 M4 Server Intel Xeon E31220/3.10Ghz RAM 16GB HDD 1TB
$79.00
![IBM x3650 M4 2x Xeon E5-2670 2.6ghz 16-Core / 64GB / M5110e / 2x PSU picture](/store/img/YXgAAOSwzGNjh6tH/s-l225//IBM-x3650-M4-2x-Xeon-E5-2670-2-6ghz-16-Core-64GB-M.jpg)
IBM x3650 M4 2x Xeon E5-2670 2.6ghz 16-Core / 64GB / M5110e / 2x PSU
$229.99