-
Senior Member
registered user
Having reviewed this thread, I offer this summary, FWIW.
I have a Dell 1545 that's about two years old. It has a Broadcom wifi
which uses the wl driver. Knoppixes from 6.2 through 6.7.1, luckily
for me, work without any attention on my part to identify and to
install this driver. Very few other Linuxes do so without a LOT of
extra effort.
However, I observe that getting the right match for a Broadcom wifi
can be a tricky matter. I recommend the following reference in sorting
this out, at least insofar as deciding which Dells work with wl:
http://www.broadcom.com/docs/linux_sta/README.txt
In my case, lspci -n | grep 14e4 gives 0c:00.0 0280: 14e4:4315 (rev 01)
and I did not need to dis-install any other drivers nor change any
blacklists.
This thread shows how Alphonsu worked through this problem for a
situation that required actually removing some conflicting drivers
as suggested in the Broadcom reference. His post #19 seems to spell-out
the secret to solving his problem.
If all else fails, perhaps a personal message to Klaus2008 may get
you some competent and patient help.
-
I greatly appreciate the help; in the end I concluded Knoppix would fit well as my desktop's 2nd linux OS. Even so, I'm sure I'll have more questions in the future
-
Senior Member
registered user
@ tmq
Nice to hear your appreciation,
but can't imagine Knoppix as #2.
;D
-
Why not #2?
Knoppix cannot handle users, does not use passwords and isn't designed for security updates.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Greetings, Werner.
I can't imagine Knoppix as my #2 Linux.
It best meets my needs & lack of expertise.
I think your comment may be the best short answer
to the question of how Knoppix & Debian are different.
I can imagine more expert Linux users, certainly commercial
and professional users, may have other first choices.
Also, I count on you, KK and a few others on this
forum to keep me out of trouble.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Greetings again, ChriguK.
I think I can help you. Please refer to this confusing reference:
http://linuxwireless.org/en/users/Drivers/b43/
What it says is the Broadcom 43224 works with BOTH b43 and wl drivers.
You probably know the wl driver works for you and it's a lot easier to
get it working with wl. That was the case with Knoppix 6.7.
Knoppix 6.7 favored wl for this reason.
Knoppix 7 tries to accommodate all or most Broadcom units and
does so by eliminating the wl-driver category. We felt safe in doing
this based on the reference above. If you stare at the table long
enough I think it says there are NO cases which require wl that are
not, in principle, ok with b43, given the availability of the required
firmware.
The hitch I think you have run into is that if you insist on installing
wl yourself, said installation will blacklist the b43 driver that is
probably just fine for your hardware. Things just go downhill from
there.
I suggest you start over and see if Knoppix 7 can't install b43 and
get you going on your way. Forget what you know about wl.
Get back to us on this either way.
Last edited by utu; 07-01-2012 at 07:04 PM.
Tags for this Thread
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Vintage DEC/CLEARPOINT INC. -QRAM-2 SAB-1 1MB Q-BUS MEMORY MSV11-QA (B2)
$129.99
*NEW UNOPENED* Vintage DEC LB-5923 Keyboard
$40.00
Vintage DEC/The Redac mini cabinet front panel Digital Equipment Corp. 19"
$269.99
Vintage DEC Digital Equipment Corp PDP 11/40 G114 16K SENSE/INHIBIT (B10)
$269.99
Vintage DEC Digital Equipment Corp. DECstation 320SX Computer B7
$299.99
Vintage Digital DEC DECstation Storage Expansion SCSI external enclosure
$69.95
DEC DIGITAL Equipment Corp VT220-D2 Vintage CRT Terminal
$215.00
DEC PDP 8/M PDP 8M / 4 avail / Vintage Digital Equipment Corp /Also DEC PDP 12
$5775.00
VINTAGE DEC Digital DV11 DISTRIBUTION PANEL 5411153
$189.99
Vintage DEC Digital Rainbow Drive Controller PC100 RD51 CNTLR
$69.99