-
WiFi Work-Around for those w/B43 Requirement
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
@ luther
I expect Klaus2008 may be able to show you how, but
building and installing b43 from scratch is probably a more difficult exercise than you want to undertake.
If or when Klaus K tackles this problem, I would expect to see the result around mid-year in an update on Knoppix 7.0.
I would not necessarily expect to see an amended 6.7.1.
An external wifi, compatible with your computer would be a possible interim solution.
I use that approach to get some of the other distributions going.
Knoppx Forum Members,
I agree with utu, that an interim solution be possible. This is NOT something I have
tried, but would this be a valid candidate:
http://www.amazon.com/SANOXY-Wireles...3593945&sr=8-4
Reply requested, please . . .
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
luther
I need more details of your external wifi setup
I use a Netgear wg111v2 to work with Ubuntu & clones. See, for example:
http://support.netgear.com/app/products/model/a_id/2557
I bought mine from Surplus a few years back for $10 or $15.
This gets around my Broadcom nightmare with Ubuntu clones.
It might help for Knoppix. I can't say, since I never needed it for that.
-
Senior Member
registered user
@ luther, in re your Post #21 about an 'N' dongle:
This is a neat-looking little gadget at the right price, but it may not serve for two reasons:
1. Many routers work with a & g but not N; N is fairly new.
edit: I see it is n/g/b, so that's probably not a problem; g is ok.
2. There's always a chance it needs a driver no linuxer has come up with.
Does this sound familiar?
Your best interim solution so far is Knoppix 6.4.3, and that's not bad.
Last edited by utu; 04-20-2012 at 04:06 PM.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Addendum to my post #23, in re Sanoxy 'N' dongle.
One of the Amazon comments states that the unit works fine on linux
by installing a driver via ndiswrapper.
I think this may mean this device is a b43 candidate for fwcutter these days.
If so, that's the problem we're already wrestling with, not a solution.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Status summary on Broadcom wl vs b43 snag
.
Here's an interesting comparison, looking at Knopppix 6.4.4 relative to
luther's Posts #16 and #20 for Knoppix 6.4.3:
Code:
knoppix@Microknoppix:~$ ls /lib/modules/*/kernel/drivers/net/wireless
adm8211.ko atmel_cs.ko iwmc3200wifi p54 wl.ko
airo.ko atmel_pci.ko libertas prism54 wl1251
airo_cs.ko b43legacy libertas_tf ray_cs.ko wl12xx
at76c50x-usb.ko hostap mac80211_hwsim.ko rndis_wlan.ko wl3501_cs.ko
ath ipw2x00 mwl8k.ko rt2x00 zd1201.ko
atmel.ko iwlwifi orinoco rtl818x zd1211rw
I think this means 6.4.4 has a kernel with wl built-in, lacking b43;
whereas 6.4.3 has a kernel with b43 built-in, lacking wl.
Hint:
wl.ko shows up in 6.4.4 which I use, and b43.ko shows up in luther's 6.4.3
So, I think this means we have to consider not only offering (at least)
two drivers, but two kernels-to-match as well, for Broadcom users.
Interestingly so, this actually occurred with Knoppix 6.4.3 and 6.4.4
taken together as one distribution. One size does not fit all here.
-
Beta test complete
Summary:
Further Broadcom support requested to Developer.
-
Senior Member
registered user
We will be lucky if Klaus K doesn't ban Broadcom wifis altogther from future consideration,
as being a lot more trouble than its worth.
I know of no current linux distro that supports both b43 and wl; it's either one or the other.
The tangled list of which PCI-ID goes with which driver would make a nice hardware museum.
-
Keep Linux open
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
We will be lucky if Klaus K doesn't ban Broadcom wifis altogther from future consideration,
as being a lot more trouble than its worth.
I know of no current linux distro that supports both b43 and wl; it's either one or the other.
The tangled list of which PCI-ID goes with which driver would make a nice hardware museum.
Dear utu:
What excites me about the IBM PC/Clones is the ability to OPEN the hood! Software has always lagged behind and needs to catch-up! Software "101" in the distro world should be wireless networking. I've got NO use for the burnt ISO's that fail this basic hurdle.
I found another keeper here:
http://lubuntu.net/blog/lubuntu-1104-released
Thanks for your prompt replies.
luther
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
.
Here's an interesting comparison, looking at Knopppix 6.4.4 relative to
luther's Posts #16 and #20 for Knoppix 6.4.3:
Code:
knoppix@Microknoppix:~$ ls /lib/modules/*/kernel/drivers/net/wireless
adm8211.ko atmel_cs.ko iwmc3200wifi p54 wl.ko
airo.ko atmel_pci.ko libertas prism54 wl1251
airo_cs.ko b43legacy libertas_tf ray_cs.ko wl12xx
at76c50x-usb.ko hostap mac80211_hwsim.ko rndis_wlan.ko wl3501_cs.ko
ath ipw2x00 mwl8k.ko rt2x00 zd1201.ko
atmel.ko iwlwifi orinoco rtl818x zd1211rw
I think this means 6.4.4 has a kernel with wl built-in, lacking b43;
whereas 6.4.3 has a kernel with b43 built-in, lacking wl.
Hint:
wl.ko shows up in 6.4.4 which I use, and b43.ko shows up in luther's 6.4.3
So, I think this means we have to consider not only offering (at least)
two drivers, but two kernels-to-match as well, for Broadcom users.
Interestingly so, this actually occurred with Knoppix 6.4.3 and 6.4.4
taken together as one distribution. One size does not fit all here.
In trying this on Klaus K, I think there's a better, more plausible explanation:
The kernel in 6.7.1 may not have been built to accept b43 modules,
whereas, it appears 6.4.3/6.4.4 if they contain the same kernel DO accept both wl & b43 modules.
If that's the case, 6.7.1 surely favors only wl at the expense of ALL potential b43 users.
This turns out to be easily remedied by making sure future kernels don't preclude using
all likely useful modules. It does NOT imply a proliferation of kernels.
-
Senior Member
registered user
![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
utu
The kernel in 6.7.1 may not have been built to accept b43 modules
Klaus2008's post #7 is crucial here.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
![HP Workstation Z640 2x Xeon E5-2623V3 32GB Ram 2x256GB SSD Quadro K420 NO OS GA picture](/store/img/rIQAAOSwN9Nlnw4a/s-l225//HP-Workstation-Z640-2x-Xeon-E5-2623V3-32GB-Ram-2x2.jpg)
HP Workstation Z640 2x Xeon E5-2623V3 32GB Ram 2x256GB SSD Quadro K420 NO OS GA
$154.98
![Lenovo ThinkStation P920 2x Xeon Gold 6128 3.40GHZ 128GB DDR4 RAM No HDD TESTED picture](/store/img/prkAAOSwafdmmXon/s-l225//Lenovo-ThinkStation-P920-2x-Xeon-Gold-6128-3-40GHZ.jpg)
Lenovo ThinkStation P920 2x Xeon Gold 6128 3.40GHZ 128GB DDR4 RAM No HDD TESTED
$504.95
![Dell Poweredge R730xd LFF 14-Bay 2U Server | Choose Your CPU & RAM Config picture](/store/img/CdkAAOSwY0BmYMoF/s-l225//Dell-Poweredge-R730xd-LFF-14-Bay-2U-Server-Choose-.jpg)
Dell Poweredge R730xd LFF 14-Bay 2U Server | Choose Your CPU & RAM Config
$439.99
![Matched pair Intel Xeon E5-2667v4 SR2P5 3.20GHz, 8 core, 25MB Processors LGA2011 picture](/store/img/zYMAAOSwhh1mdEYc/s-l225//Matched-pair-Intel-Xeon-E5-2667v4-SR2P5-3-20GHz-8-.jpg)
Matched pair Intel Xeon E5-2667v4 SR2P5 3.20GHz, 8 core, 25MB Processors LGA2011
$62.95
![Intel Xeon E5-2680 V4 CPU 2.4~3.3GHz 14-Core 35M LGA 2011-3 R3 Server SR2N7 120W picture](/store/img/hLcAAOSwA81iMQ7h/s-l225//Intel-Xeon-E5-2680-V4-CPU-2-4-3-3GHz-14-Core-35M-L.jpg)
Intel Xeon E5-2680 V4 CPU 2.4~3.3GHz 14-Core 35M LGA 2011-3 R3 Server SR2N7 120W
$15.99
![Intel Xeon E5-2680 V3 2.50Ghz 12 Core 30MB Cache LGA 2011-3 CPU SR1XP Tested picture](/store/img/M1EAAOSwdAdjG8AH/s-l225//Intel-Xeon-E5-2680-V3-2-50Ghz-12-Core-30MB-Cache-L.jpg)
Intel Xeon E5-2680 V3 2.50Ghz 12 Core 30MB Cache LGA 2011-3 CPU SR1XP Tested
$5.90
![INTEL Xeon E5-2697 V4 SR2JV 2.30GHZ 18-Core CPU 2697v4 GRADE A CONDITION @ E picture](/store/img/RSEAAOSwt21kUDvm/s-l225//INTEL-Xeon-E5-2697-V4-SR2JV-2-30GHZ-18-Core-CPU-26.jpg)
INTEL Xeon E5-2697 V4 SR2JV 2.30GHZ 18-Core CPU 2697v4 GRADE A CONDITION @ E
$39.00
![Intel Xeon Gold 6138 2.0GHz 27.5MB 20-Core 125W LGA3647 SR3B5 picture](/store/img/U4wAAOSw~HJka8-T/s-l225//Intel-Xeon-Gold-6138-2-0GHz-27-5MB-20-Core-125W-LG.jpg)
Intel Xeon Gold 6138 2.0GHz 27.5MB 20-Core 125W LGA3647 SR3B5
$37.00
![HP Z440 Workstation 18Cores Xeon E5-2699 V3 128GB 1TB SSD 2TB WIFI WIN11 R5-340X picture](/store/img/itIAAOSwjT9mKCN6/s-l225//HP-Z440-Workstation-18Cores-Xeon-E5-2699-V3-128GB-.jpg)
HP Z440 Workstation 18Cores Xeon E5-2699 V3 128GB 1TB SSD 2TB WIFI WIN11 R5-340X
$309.99
![HP Z6 G4 Workstation Xeon Silver 4116 1.5TB SSD 1TB HDD 16GB B Win 11 Pro M4000 picture](/store/img/4s0AAOSwYgFmc0S0/s-l225//HP-Z6-G4-Workstation-Xeon-Silver-4116-1-5TB-SSD-1T.jpg)
HP Z6 G4 Workstation Xeon Silver 4116 1.5TB SSD 1TB HDD 16GB B Win 11 Pro M4000
$349.00