-
Usb as read-only
Hello,
my first post here
I would like to know if itīs possible to boot my knoppix (in a usb pen drive) as read-only. Once I finished my setup in persistence I value more my security than anything else, and so I donīt want something changed or somebody "hacking" my pen drive and changing my knoppix with malware, even not adding more to the persistent image but using my setup.
Thanks a lot.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Originally Posted by
jalb
Hello,
my first post here
I would like to know if itīs possible to boot my knoppix (in a usb pen drive) as read-only. Once I finished my setup in persistence I value more my security than anything else, and so I donīt want something changed or somebody "hacking" my pen drive and changing my knoppix with malware, even not adding more to the persistent image but using my setup.
Thanks a lot.
Greetings, jalb.
SDHCs have a little tab which allow you to select read-only; I don't know about pen drives.
That would make your LiveUSB more like a LiveDVD; however, you too won't be able to change it when it's read only.
You may want to look into the efficacy of using encryption as your defense against hacking & malware.
I think that's the standard approach to the problem.
Also, you need say whether your persistence is in a separate partition or not.
-
Originally Posted by
utu
Greetings, jalb.
SDHCs have a little tab which allow you to select read-only; I don't know about pen drives.
That would make your LiveUSB more like a LiveDVD; however, you too won't be able to change it when it's read only.
You may want to look into the efficacy of using encryption as your defense against hacking & malware.
I think that's the standard approach to the problem.
Also, you need say whether your persistence is in a separate partition or not.
Thank you stu
Sorry, I donīt know what is SDHC.
The problem is not about encryption only (thatīs not my problem, I always like to use encryption) but malware and destroying all my persistent image.
Thatīs why when I finished the settings in my persistent image I would like to keep it "safer".
If I choose a different partition the problem is still the same, because when I am using knoppix (and itīs not a safe s.o. avoiding new updates, etc) someone could get access and change everything.
Thanks!
-
Senior Member
registered user
Greetings again, jalb.
I sympathize with your concerns, but I think you can have it your way
if you put up with a little inconvenience here and there.
Persistence has to be read/write when it's updated.
If you have persistence on a separate partition, you can probably
move it back and forth between r/o & r/w. That's being awfully cautious
if that partition is alread encrypted.
If your use Knoppix as a Frugal install or a LiveUSB, the master KNOPPIX
file is in a compacted form that can be self-checked very easily to see if
you or anyone else has changed it. There is rarely any sense in doing
a 'hard disk install of Knoppix', you will learn to hate that.
An SDHC is a SecureDigital memory card, HC perhaps meaning High(er)
Capacity; higher than just SD, that is. Developed for digital cameras
and printers, some PCs also have an SD/SDHC adapter connected to the USB bus.
SDHCs cost less than 1$ per Gb these days in sizes appropriate to
LiveUSB usage. If you have a USB port, but not an SD/SDHX slot, then
Sony and others make an inexpensive USB-to-SD/SDHC adapter for ~$20.
-
Thatīs great stu!
But how can I move persistence to a different partition and make it work or telling knoppix where to boot?, do you mean to some hard disk inside the computer and then changing some route and making this partition read-only?. Do you think knoppix will work with encrypted read-only persistence?. I only use knoppix as live usb, never as a hard disk install.
If I use persistence normally (read/write) then itīs always changing stu, it would be hard to check it every day.
I understand about SDHC now
Thanks a lot.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Originally Posted by
jalb
how can I move persistence to a different partition and make it work or telling knoppix where to boot?
As you set out to make your Knoppix LiveUSB, you have choices along the way. One choice is to have persistence on a separate (reiserfs)
partition; another choice is whether to encrypt or not. Once you have your LiveUSB it's up to you to rummage around and change things.
Maybe you can make the persistence file read-only. Your persistence will not change until you set it back to read-write. This is up to you.
Take some chances, try things out. You can always start over if something goes wrong. Cheers.
-
Once I finished with all my setup (as I am using my knoppix with persistance now), how can I move it?. Can I change now the "normal" persistence file to read-only and it will work as usual?.
Thanks again stu.
---- Full quote deleted
wps
Last edited by Werner P. Schulz; 01-18-2015 at 09:50 PM.
-
Senior Member
registered user
Originally Posted by
jalb
Can I change now the "normal" persistence file to read-only and it will work as usual?.
I would expect if you make persistence read-only then it won't collect any changes until you reset it to read-write.
Isn't that what you would expect? And why don't you just try it and find out?
-
Yes, I tried when I fninshed writing my answer but knoppix didn't let me to change the pernissions of the persistent image (root console).
Thank you anyway.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
SRF8Z Intel Xeon Gold 6244 8-Core 3.60GHz 24.75MB 150W Processor ***New Other***
$1590.00
Supermicro 4U 4x Nvidia GPU AI Server 3.8Ghz 8-Core 512GB 2x10G SFP+ 2x2200W
$3848.00
Supermicro 4U 4x Nvidia GPU AI Server 3.8Ghz 8-Core 192GB 2x10G SFP+ 2x2200W
$3380.00
Supermicro 4U 4x Nvidia GPU AI Server 3.8Ghz 8-Core 64GB 2x10G SFP+ 2x2200W
$3180.00
Intel - Core i9-13900K 13th Gen 24 cores 8 P-cores + 16 E-cores 36M Cache, 3 ...
$689.99
Intel - Core i7-13700K 13th Gen 16 cores 8 P-cores + 8 E-cores 30M Cache, 3.4...
$489.99
AMD Ryzen 9 5950X 16-core 32-thread Desktop Processor
$319.99
Intel - Core i9-12900K Desktop Processor 16 (8P+8E) Cores up to 5.2 GHz Unloc...
$619.99
Dell Optiplex 7060 SFF 8th Gen Core i7 3.2GHZ 32GB 512GB Win 11 Pro
$249.00
Dell OPTIPLEX 7080 Micro PC i5-10500T @ 2.30GHz 16GB RAM 240GB Win 10 PC Desktop
$249.99