Any feedback on this please?
When using flash-knoppix to install knoppix on USB, first it asks whether you would like to create an overlay file and then, afterwards, it asks if you want to remaster knoppix.
What is the difference between the overlay and the remaster thing?
I always considered the overlay as a "simple" (but not actual) remaster.
What does knoppix do on the USB if you answer Yes to the remaster question please?
Thanks in advance.
Any feedback on this please?
I haven't tried that option, but in general, remastering means creating a new compressed image, while overlays are stacked compressed file system modifications relative to the rest of the stack.
So if you have a series of overlays, you might consider a remastering to collapse that stack and get better efficiency.
Thanks for your reply Capricorny. That is how I understand it as well.
However, at install time, whether you choose to Remaster or not, it still creates KNOPPIX2 as a stacked compressed file system and, as far as I know, there is no option (script?) in Knoppix to generate a remastered image. There was once a script by Werner P. Schulz to create a remastered image but now the website does not exist any more. It would be great if such script are integrated in the Live DVD since it would make remastering much easier.
What is going on, I think, is that a slightly more "advanced" form of remastering is done, where the cloop images are created subject to the 4GB filesize constraint. The overlays are collapsed, but two non-overlapping images are created. If your files are to reside on less restricted file systems, you don't need to care about that - unless there is some limits in cloop file creation. I mostly use a "knoppified" version of plain Debian now, and there squashfs is used. But the principle for remastering is exactly the same.
I think you should not let the lack of updated scripts stop you. There are several code snippets posted here through the years to work from.
Now I have tried the "remaster" option, and it seems to me that the new overlay KNOPPIX2 is simply created on top of KNOPPIX and KNOPPIX1. Which may seem like a nuisance if you have purged a lot of packages to make room for new programs, but isn't really too bad for most ordinary use cases. I use both standard Debian (live) and Knoppix, and while I will stick to the ordinary remastering procedure for Debian, I think this "shallow" remastering will suffice for my Knoppix use.
One of the real handy features of frequent remastering, is that the system may often be run without persistent store, which means, among other things, that errors or malware that is introduced will not survive the next reboot.
Dell XPS 8930 Gaming Desktop Core i7 9th 8-core 1TB HDD 20GB RAM NVIDIA GTX GPU
$399.00
HP Workstation Z640 2x Xeon E5-2623V4 32GB Ram Dual 256GB SSD K420 Linux GA
$234.98
Dell OptiPlex 3060 SFF Core i5 8500, 8GB RAM, 128GB SSD, Windows 11 Home
$159.99
Dell OptiPlex 7040 Intel core I7-6700 3.4 GHz 8 GB ram No HDD/No OS
$59.99
EXCELLENT 2020-2022 iMac 27" 5K, 3.8 GHz 8-Core i7, 1TB SSD, 64GB RAM, 5500XT
$1765.00
AMD Ryzen 9 5950X 16-core 32-thread Desktop Processor
$319.99
HP ProDesk 400 G5 SFF Intel Core i3-8100 3.60GHz, 8GB 256GB SSD, Win10 & Power
$60.00
Intel Xeon E5-2667 V2 LGA 2011 3.3GHz 8 Core 130W 25MB 8GT/s CPU Processor
$24.00
HP Chromebase Desktop PC 21.5" FHD Core i3-10110U Intel UHD 8GB DDR4 128GB SSD
$356.19
Dell Optiplex 5040 MT Core i5-6500 3.20GHZ 8GB RAM 256GB SSD Win 10 Pro WiFi
$89.99