Just off the top of my head:
tar tvf tar1.tar > output1.txt
tar tvf tar2.tar > output2.txt
diff output1.txt output2.txt > diff.txt
Ok i may seem retarded, but if i have two tarballs, one is of a file system and the other is the same filesystem with changes
how can i get a new tarball that has just the differences between the two. There are a couple gigs apiece so i really didn't want to uncompress both to do a diff. is that the only option?
Just off the top of my head:
tar tvf tar1.tar > output1.txt
tar tvf tar2.tar > output2.txt
diff output1.txt output2.txt > diff.txt
thought of that but it wouldn't give the difference between two files with different contents and same size
Correct. If you need to guarantee bit-level uniqueness then you are probably left with the option of with complete extraction of the tar & then logging & comparing cryptographic hashes (MD5 or SHA1).

5 Port Gigabit Unmanaged Ethernet Switch, Home Network Hub, Office Ethernet S...
$9.64
NETGEAR GS308EP Essential Series 8-Port Gigabit PoE+ Unmanaged Switch
$49.99
Cisco Catalyst 2960-48TT-L 48-Port Fast Ethernet Managed Rackmount Switch
$46.99
5Ports Gigabit Network Switch w/ 4 PoE+ Ports Total 52W each port 30W Plug&Play
$31.99
TP-Link TL-SG105 5-Port Gigabit Ethernet Unmanaged Metal Desktop Network Switch
$19.99
10-Port Gigabit PoE Network Switch with 8 PoE+ Ports with 2 Combo SFP Slots 125W
$39.99
TP-Link TL-SG105, 5 Port Gigabit Unmanaged Ethernet Switch, Network Hub, Ethern
$15.25
Arista DCS-7010T-48-R 48P 1GbE 4P 10GbE SFP+ RA Switch with rack mounts
$69.00
D-Link DGS-1210-28P 28-Port PoE Gigabit Web Smart Switch With Cord
$49.99
Linksys LGS328MPC 24-Port Managed Gigabit PoE+ Switch with 4 10G SFP+ Uplinks
$224.95