Go into File--Preferences--Expert Features and select the check box that says "Enable image recorder for all supported recorder formats."
I found this by trial and error under the exact same circumstances and it worked for me.

It is also worth noting that I have had problems in the past burning a CD on one computer and then trying to get it to read on another...
What I discovered was this:

Disabling UDMA mode in your BIOS for the secondary master (or whatever channel your burner is on) and running your burner in PIO mode seems to correct any such compatibility problems with burning on one computer and running it on another.

Am I totally nuts here or has someone else discovered this as well?...

Anyway, let me know if this setting change works for you.
It did for me.